Impact of Digitalization on Educators: An Overview of Its Psychological Effects on Teachers

Tech Troubles: The Unforeseen Woes of Digital Education for Teachers

• *

Struggling with the Digital Transition: Teachers' Main Sources of Stress - Impact of Digitalization on Educators: An Overview of Its Psychological Effects on Teachers

From network blackouts and printer jams to updates and malfunctions, as education transforms digitally, so do the technical messes. Teachers are usually tasked with rectifying these issues on their own. "Digital transformation is causing a huge workload surge and tech-related stress for teachers," says Thilo Hartmann, chairman of the Education and Science Union (GEW) in Hesse.

Teachers prepare lessons under the assumption that technology will function seamlessly. "When something goes awry, there's often no one to turn to. Teachers are left grappling with tech issues themselves," Hartmann laments.

In numerous schools, tech-savvy individuals assume responsibility for IT support, taking on these responsibilities as a side endeavor. "A select group of teachers, who have some background in technology, chip in whenever they can," Hartmann states. At some schools, guidance counselors are promoted to senior counselors and given a slight pay bump. Others witness a slight reduction in teaching hours. "However, at many, particularly smaller schools, it's just another task piled on."

Maintaining devices is a time-consuming affair

At a school housing approximately 1,000 students and a hundred teachers, there's a considerable number of devices to maintain. "It's a double-edged sword that can't simply be handled on the side. Companies have an IT department, but schools don't," Hartmann protests.

"It starts with equipment in computer labs breaking down. There are technical problems, sometimes the internet falters." A quick resolution is necessary to prevent disruptions in classes. Devices need regular updates, system security ensured, and data maintained. This process can be extremely time-consuming and requires learning new systems and coordination efforts.

Kassel's Tech Support Squad

The "IT Supporter@School" project in Kassel aims to ease the burden on teachers. The city has recruited 12 IT supporters, each supporting six schools. "Schools have admitted they can no longer provide this technical support," says Mayor and Education Commissioner Nicole Maisch (Greens). "These are educators, not IT professionals, taking on these tasks over and above their regular duties."

IT supporter Thorben Schröder elucidates that he handles issues that can be resolved on-site. He and his colleagues serve as the schools' point of contact for problems and wishes, visiting regularly and of course in case of emergencies.

"When my iPad malfunctions, it's a problem," says Carsten Horstmann, deputy head of the Johann-Amos-Comenius School. The perk of IT supporters lies in their ability to resolve problems promptly, before teachers can get swamped. "It's become a far more pleasant experience," he says.

School's Digital Infrastructure

The digital infrastructure in schools has been built, in part, through generous funding from the federal and state governments via the Digital Pact I, reveals Maisch. Now, it's about helping the 55 schools in Kassel ensure reliable digital teaching environments. "Teachers should anticipate smooth operation. Our goal is to allow teachers to focus on their jobs without tech flaws sapping too much time and energy."

The Hessian Ministry of Culture recognizes the complexities inherent in the digitalization of schools. "The digitalization of classrooms mirrors the challenges that accompany the introduction of modern technologies," they said. Progress has been made in areas such as adapting existing structures, promoting skills among all stakeholders, and ensuring resources. "Yet, continued technological advancement necessitates ongoing effort to successfully navigate this progress."

The aim of digitalization is to assist teachers in administrative tasks and amplify individual student support. "The digital applications provided by the state and school carriers alleviate teachers in many areas, according to the ministry. In the realm of IT equipment, the state supports initiatives that relieve teachers in daily use."

Digitalization in Hessian schools has witnessed significant strides in recent years. "This advancement has been made possible, in large part, due to the funding provided by the state to significantly boost the investment volume for school IT infrastructure in the Digital Pact." This ensures schools across the state are equipped with IT infrastructure that facilitates modern, digitally supported teaching.

GEW: Some Progress, but Room to Improve

"Digitalization in schools has received a massive boost due to the Corona pandemic. However, we are far from our ultimate goals," laments GEW state chairman Hartmann. Emergency funds are necessary in the coming years to address the maintenance backlog, as equipment is now reaching a stage where it needs to be replaced in the next few years. "There's no plan yet as to how this will be funded," Hartmann highlights.

GEW also advocates for expanded media education. Digital media literacy surpasses simple computer use and internet browsing. "Digitalization should be critically examined, not viewed as an end in itself," said Hartmann. Equal digital resources should be available in all schools.

Insight

Managing technical challenges in schools due to digitalization poses several hurdles for teachers and the need for IT support, but solutions exist to address these issues.

Challenges

1. Lack of Training and Increased Teacher Burden:
2. Teachers struggle to keep up with rapidly evolving digital tools and fail to effectively integrate them into classroom practices. Continuous training is essential but can consume time and resources, potentially increasing workload[2].
3. A lack of pedagogical understanding of digital tools can impair their effective use in the classroom, leading to frustration and increased workload for teachers[2].
4. IT Support Deficits and Infrastructure:
5. Schools may lack sufficient IT infrastructure and support, leading to technical issues like connectivity problems, outdated software, and hardware failures[5].
6. The digital divide can exacerbate these issues, as some schools may not have the resources to invest in modern technology, resulting in disparities in access to digital tools[5].
7. Distractions and Classroom Management:
8. The use of technology in the classroom can introduce distractions, such as social media, games, and irrelevant websites, which teachers must manage while keeping a focus on learning objectives[1].
9. Ensuring students stay engaged and minimize distractions requires effective classroom management strategies and tools like single sign-on platforms[1].

Solutions

1. Ongoing Professional Development:
2. Providing teachers with ongoing professional development opportunities is vital. This consists of training not only on digital tools but also on how to integrate them effectively into pedagogical practices[2].
3. Encouraging teachers to share best practices and collaborate can help address common challenges and improve technology integration[2].
4. Improved IT Support:
5. Investment in infrastructure: Prioritizing investments in robust IT infrastructure, such as dependable internet connections and modern hardware, will minimize technical problems[5].
6. Centralized IT services: Implementing centralized IT services can facilitate efficient management and resolution of technical problems, ensuring learning is uninterrupted[1].
7. Classroom Management Tools:
8. Utilizing single sign-on platforms, like Clever and ClassLink, can help manage digital resources and reduce distractions by keeping students focused on educational content[1].
9. Adopting ad blockers and content filtering can decrease distractions and ensure students access only relevant learning resources[1].
10. Addressing the Digital Divide:
11. Collaborations between public and private sectors can provide funding for initiatives that promote equal access to technology in schools and communities[5].
12. Implementing affordable internet solutions in underserved areas can bridge the digital divide and ensure all students have access to digital learning tools[5].

By addressing these challenges and implementing these solutions, schools can effectively manage technical problems and guarantee that digital transformation serves to enhance learning rather than hindering it.

1. Within the digital transformation of education, vocational training for teachers in technology and digital literacy becomes crucial to ease the tech-related stress caused by malfunctions and network issues, as stated by Thilo Hartmann, Chairman of the Education and Science Union (GEW) in Hesse.
2. In the pursuit of fostering a seamless digital educational environment, it is essential to establish robust community policies outlining the funding, infrastructure, and technical support for schools, as acknowledged by the Hessian Ministry of Culture in their recognition of the complexities of school digitalization.

Read also: