Skip to content

MSU Backtracks After Criticism: Student Leader's Free Speech Rights Upheld

MSU disciplined student leader Kara Spencer for sending emails to faculty. After criticism from civil liberties groups and students, the university withdrew the charges, raising concerns about academic freedom.

In this picture, we see the poster containing the college of the cartoons. We see some text written...
In this picture, we see the poster containing the college of the cartoons. We see some text written on this poster.

MSU Backtracks After Criticism: Student Leader's Free Speech Rights Upheld

Michigan State University (MSU) faced criticism from civil liberties groups and students after disciplining student government leader Kara Spencer for exercising her free speech rights. Spencer was initially accused of violating MSU's 'spam' policy by sending emails to faculty members.

Thirteen civil liberties organizations penned an open letter to MSU President Lou Anna K. Simon, challenging the university's policy and its application against Spencer. The Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (FIRE) and other groups supported Spencer's cause, arguing that her actions were protected by the First Amendment.

Spencer's troubles began when she sent an email to professors, reaching eight percent of MSU's 5,000 faculty members, criticizing administration plans to shorten the academic calendar. MSU Network Administrator Randall J. Hall summoned Spencer for a meeting, alleging she violated MSU policies by sending 'spam'. Despite appeals, Spencer was found guilty and received a formal warning in her file.

MSU refused to suspend or revoke the controversial policy, leaving students under the impression that it was still enforced. Spencer, undeterred, sent her version of the University Committee on Student Affairs' (UCSA) letter to 391 faculty members, arguing against the proposed changes. The other four universities on FIRE's Red Alert list, along with MSU, are Rutgers University, University of Arizona, University of Colorado Boulder, and Western Michigan University.

After facing backlash from students and civil liberties organizations, MSU withdrew the 'spamming' charges against Spencer. The university's actions raised concerns about academic freedom and students' rights to express their opinions. The incident highlighted the need for universities to review and clarify their policies regarding student expression and communication.

Read also:

Latest